Humans – vs – computers

Artificial Intelligence gains ground every year, now and can do some things better than humans, even when this wasn’t thought possible. They’re far better than humans at Chess, for example; now used by even the best players to check on their moves.

Despite all this, I don’t think computers will ever produce art in the same way that we do. Music – all art, really – is something special, conveying the very essence of the human condition.

The video above is a recent rendition of Bach’s BWV974 Concerto in D Minor, Adagio. Spotify has 100s of different versions of the exact same piece, and each player interprets it in a slightly different way. Some interpret it in a very different way. I happen to like Ólafsson’s version the very best of all. I can’t quite tell you why – I’d be committing the same mistake that the computer is about to make, below: of attempting to quantify the sublime.

Here’s a computer version I recorded playing that same, wonderful transcription, but with little of the soul:

Bach BWV974 Concerto in D Minor – Adagio

A computer is a wonderful tool for making music – especially my kind of music. But it is not the composer, not the conductor, and certainly not the musician. A computer is merely an instrument.